Martha Southgates's editorial in the New York Times Book Review has been buzzing through the blogosphere. Her essay reflects on the glass ceiling Black writers face after publishing two or three novels.
"I am a 46-year-old writer of “literary” fiction. I’ve had three novels published — the first for young people, the last two for adults. All have won minor prizes, been respectfully reviewed and sold modestly. I’ve been awarded a few fairly competitive fellowships and grants. The business is full of fiction writers like me. With one difference: I’m black, born and raised in the United States. At the parties and conferences I attend, and in the book reviews I read, I rarely encounter other African-American “literary” writers, particularly in my age bracket. There just don’t seem to be that many of us out there, and that’s something I’ve come to wonder about a great deal. And so I got on the phone with some editors and African-American writers to talk about it."
She writes with heroic concern about the fact that writers such as Toni Morrison and Ralph Ellison (who I don't believe fits well into this because of his writer's block and self doubt was so devastating) for all their greatness, published sporadically and were in their forties before true success arrived. As I enter my mid-forties with hopes of writing I did take some offense at the thought that 40 was somewhat late in life. But I'll leave that for another post.
Martha, who I met once and seemed lovely, is doomed. Sorry, Martha. On one level there's an assumption that being published is a right and not a privilege. She buys into the myth of the traditional publishing dynamic that's dangled in front of her every time a White writer is published.
The old publishing world: I write, you publish. Success!
The new publishing world: I write, you, my German-owned-conglomerate publisher, find a niche that's comfortable for you, I work that niche until there's no hair left on it, all the while looking for traditional and new media options to help synergize and commodify my talent to help lift the marketing burden off you. Oprah, please call. Success!?
Publishers investing in writers based on talent is rare. As a
magazine publisher, and potential publicity vehicle- the writers' mantra is, "but my publisher is investing no money in my book..." This is the Flava Flav era, Martha, and only a lucky few writers (Black or White) can escape this whirlpool. In this equation, talent, is at best, an innocent bystander. The world's attention span has so drastically shifted that the issue will soon be not how many books you publish but why should you be published at all.
"Though the publishing industry remains overwhelmingly white, editors say they are always looking for good, marketable work by writers of any background. Morgan Entrekin, publisher of Grove/Atlantic, which recently published Michael Thomas’s first novel, “Man Gone Down” — one of the few novels by an African-American to grace the cover of this publication of late — said: “I don’t tend to approach the black writers we publish as African-American. I see them as writers first.” "
Almost all people have an affinity for their aspirations or history, and no matter how open-minded we profess to be these provide safe spaces. White writers and publishers no longer belong to the proverbial country and private clubs, but they do inhabit the same mental space. Similar backgrounds, cultures, tastes bind us all into definable categories -for better or worse. It's what draws Black people together like red blood cells, clotting intimately in a party filled with Whites -trying to understand why Amy Winehouse plays over and over in the background. We stand on the periphery glaring -she's the queen of soul!?
Unlike most, I not only talk the talk but I walk the walk. So here's the solution:
Every writer who considers his or herself "literary" should take on a pen pal. Preferable a chick lit or urban fiction writer. Edward P. Jones teams with Vicki Stringer, Randall Keenan with Kwan, Martha with Relentless Aaron. To avoid the dreaded public interaction pretend your pal lives in Europe and you can only communicate via email. But you should form a bound and learn. Your future is in your hands. If you want to succeed -and publish books at your pace- you have to get up everyday and work twice as hard as you worked the day before. Get a table on 1-2-5, let people know who you are and why they should read your book.
"Hey Relentless!"
"Hey Merci [nee Martha Southgate but renamed Merciless Martha at a Yoruba/hip-hop naming ceremony] . I see you out here grindin' huh?
"Gotta make that paper, baby."
"No doubt, no doubt."
"Where you headed after this, Black?"
"I'm taking a box of books to the International Black Hair Symposium, Merci. Just goin' to hang see what's poppin'."
"I feel you, son. I'll roll with you..."
Filter out my silliness and the bottom line is Relentless Aaron publishes when he wants and is not overly concerned with waiting for others to bring success to him.
That no matter how hard you work, the "big house" with it's fresh whitewashed columns, open door, and Mint Juleps will rarely be a welcoming place. You have a plow strapped to your back and you must work, i.e., sell. The plow may be an exquisite piece of craftsmanship -forged steel, well-turned and polished wood, sinewy leather straps all working in unison. But it's still a plow created so the owner can better monetize his or her crop.
This issue, framed in publishing, has nothing to do with publishing and everything to do with empowerment. Until we realize that our water can be as cold as anyone elses there will always be a pall over our success and satisfaction.